Some Mac site ripped Dangeruss :(
Wednesday, April 16, 2003 by plainsong | Discussion: WinCustomize Talk
I'm ashamed of my people - he didn't even bother to change the text in the wp.
http://www.macsnaps.com/view.php?type=desktop&id=129&clear=1050525117
http://www.macsnaps.com/view.php?type=desktop&id=129&clear=1050525117
 |
|
Page 5 of 7 | |
|
|---|
plainsong
Reply #83 Sunday, April 20, 2003 8:06 AM
Reply #83 Sunday, April 20, 2003 8:06 AM
Yeah, I'd have never reported it here, had it been a legitmate screenshot, but my first thought was "If they have Dangeruss on the first page, what else is hidden here??" 
>
>
GregBN
Reply #84 Sunday, April 20, 2003 11:58 PM
Reply #84 Sunday, April 20, 2003 11:58 PM
If I had downloaded some wallpaper from some site, and then I posted it up on my website to show my friends how impressed I was with what the artist did....
I'll end up with a bunch of holier-than-thou people screaming at me to take it down just because I was in some violation of copyright. Nevermind the fact that they never once emailed the main artist to ask him if he would present himself first and talk to the people who placed it up. No, all of you had to run head first into their little msgboard over there and start flaming the hell out of them without, let me repeat, without asking the owner of the site what purpose it was for.
Downloading something and then distributing it to other people through anything is also illegal, if people really want to be picky about it. I'm pretty sure half of you, if not more, have already broken that rule. However, we ignored that little bit of crap just because we never claimed it to be our art, the people we sent it to never asked if it was ours or not or they already knew, or we don't want to feel like we "broke the law."
Sometimes, things like these get overboard, you know? You can rip into people for uploading work that aren't theirs. You can't say "warez suck" all you want. When it really boils down to it, half the work you admit into the WinCustomize database of graphics is probably made by pirated software. Does it seem like you're talking out of your mouth and your ass at the same time?
So now what? Cover your ears with your hands and pretend this post didn't exist?
There are going to be people out there who aren't going to care too much about the world of graphics or their copyrights for that matter. However, you aren't given a badge to be internet cops to go hunt down every last piece of work done by you or your friends posted on someone else's website (automatically assuming that all uploads are for BAD REASONS).
Arrogant bastards is what I would think first hand. If I was showing my friends how much I enjoyed that specific piece of work, you guys are probably running off half the potential fans of these artists you so respect.
As far as I know, I don't think real artists mind people showing and liking their stuff. Whether you sing, dance, or make pictures... people do it for the enjoyment of others. If I had made any work and someone else uploaded it to their site to show it to their circle of friends... not claiming to have made it... I wouldn't care. What is art about? The significance of how outstanding your name is, or how significant people enjoy the work you've dedicated your time to?
When a msgboard gets over crowded by rip reports, it almost makes me want to think that all of you are too self-important to allow people to enjoy what it is that you hvae made. Just because people don't care about what you care so much doesn't mean they deserve your anger. All those titles of adminship means nothing to some people... and you guys may just end up being push-overs. Your status work only within the communites to which they are obtained at. Campus police can't arrest people outside of the campus.
Think about it, ya'll.
peace.
I'll end up with a bunch of holier-than-thou people screaming at me to take it down just because I was in some violation of copyright. Nevermind the fact that they never once emailed the main artist to ask him if he would present himself first and talk to the people who placed it up. No, all of you had to run head first into their little msgboard over there and start flaming the hell out of them without, let me repeat, without asking the owner of the site what purpose it was for.
Downloading something and then distributing it to other people through anything is also illegal, if people really want to be picky about it. I'm pretty sure half of you, if not more, have already broken that rule. However, we ignored that little bit of crap just because we never claimed it to be our art, the people we sent it to never asked if it was ours or not or they already knew, or we don't want to feel like we "broke the law."
Sometimes, things like these get overboard, you know? You can rip into people for uploading work that aren't theirs. You can't say "warez suck" all you want. When it really boils down to it, half the work you admit into the WinCustomize database of graphics is probably made by pirated software. Does it seem like you're talking out of your mouth and your ass at the same time?
So now what? Cover your ears with your hands and pretend this post didn't exist?
There are going to be people out there who aren't going to care too much about the world of graphics or their copyrights for that matter. However, you aren't given a badge to be internet cops to go hunt down every last piece of work done by you or your friends posted on someone else's website (automatically assuming that all uploads are for BAD REASONS).
Arrogant bastards is what I would think first hand. If I was showing my friends how much I enjoyed that specific piece of work, you guys are probably running off half the potential fans of these artists you so respect.
As far as I know, I don't think real artists mind people showing and liking their stuff. Whether you sing, dance, or make pictures... people do it for the enjoyment of others. If I had made any work and someone else uploaded it to their site to show it to their circle of friends... not claiming to have made it... I wouldn't care. What is art about? The significance of how outstanding your name is, or how significant people enjoy the work you've dedicated your time to?
When a msgboard gets over crowded by rip reports, it almost makes me want to think that all of you are too self-important to allow people to enjoy what it is that you hvae made. Just because people don't care about what you care so much doesn't mean they deserve your anger. All those titles of adminship means nothing to some people... and you guys may just end up being push-overs. Your status work only within the communites to which they are obtained at. Campus police can't arrest people outside of the campus.
Think about it, ya'll.
peace.
kona0197
Reply #85 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:05 AM
Reply #85 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:05 AM
Man that guy just said what I've wanted to say for a long time. (most of it anyway)
But a rip is a rip.
Stealing is stealing.
Quit ripping and stealing and maybe the msg board would not be choked up for people looking for you.
But a rip is a rip.
Stealing is stealing.
Quit ripping and stealing and maybe the msg board would not be choked up for people looking for you.
kona0197
Reply #86 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:09 AM
Reply #86 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:09 AM
In the last paragraph I was refering to Youji. But also he does make some valid points. I bet I'm not the only one using Kazaa. And this is one of the only sites I have seen that actually goes out of it's way to track down rippers.
By the way everyone I really don't think we can catch all the rippers. Here is a example: They shut down Napster but up sprung Kazaa. If they shut that Kazaa down sonething else will take it's place. We can try to kill the ripping machine but in reality it is bigger than all us put together. Want proof? Look up Hackers and Cracks on Google.
Nuff said.
By the way everyone I really don't think we can catch all the rippers. Here is a example: They shut down Napster but up sprung Kazaa. If they shut that Kazaa down sonething else will take it's place. We can try to kill the ripping machine but in reality it is bigger than all us put together. Want proof? Look up Hackers and Cracks on Google.
Nuff said.
GregBN
Reply #87 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:11 AM
Reply #87 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:11 AM
I agree, ripping is ripping. However, that guy didn't rip Dangeruss's art. He downloaded it from another website and uploaded it (for what reason we will never find out) for his friends to admire. He never claimed to have made it.
Stealing is stealing, but many huge companies gained their popularity and members because their older members distributed either by word of mouth or some sort of an example. Introducing friends to this new cool "thing" you have discovered is such a bad thing?
If so, why bother telling people about anything we do anymore?
Stealing is stealing, but many huge companies gained their popularity and members because their older members distributed either by word of mouth or some sort of an example. Introducing friends to this new cool "thing" you have discovered is such a bad thing?
If so, why bother telling people about anything we do anymore?
kona0197
Reply #88 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:15 AM
Reply #88 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:15 AM
Again you make awesome points. But beware: If the admins read all this your in for a butt kickin, and me too. 
GregBN
Reply #89 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:18 AM
Reply #89 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:18 AM
Admins can kick my butt all they want. I'm not looking for trouble, but I refuse to nod my head yes to them just because they're admins. Sometimes, the upper powers are wrong.
But truth is truth. Truth doesn't bend just because one has admin powers and the other doesn't.
But truth is truth. Truth doesn't bend just because one has admin powers and the other doesn't.
bakerstreet
Reply #90 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:19 AM
Reply #90 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:19 AM
"half the work you admit into the WinCustomize database of graphics is probably made by pirated software"
I think you are on the wrong site. Dangeruss was appreciative of what was done, so your point is pretty flat. Actually, is anyone upset about it but you? I think there is a pretty strong contingent of "real artists" online right now that are disproving the whole "If you like it pass it on" thing.
Anyway "Your status work only within the communites to which they are obtained at", and I dunno who you are.
I think you are on the wrong site. Dangeruss was appreciative of what was done, so your point is pretty flat. Actually, is anyone upset about it but you? I think there is a pretty strong contingent of "real artists" online right now that are disproving the whole "If you like it pass it on" thing.
Anyway "Your status work only within the communites to which they are obtained at", and I dunno who you are.
GregBN
Reply #91 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:23 AM
Reply #91 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:23 AM
No, of course you don't know who I am. That is the whole point. If I had status, then my points may have been too easily agreed with, wouldn't it?
I'm sure Dangeruss is appreciative, but just because one author said thank you, it doesn't mean every author will.
As for the pirated software comment, can you tell me that it is a guarantee that no one is using pirated software to make what the moderators allow through?
I'm sure Dangeruss is appreciative, but just because one author said thank you, it doesn't mean every author will.
As for the pirated software comment, can you tell me that it is a guarantee that no one is using pirated software to make what the moderators allow through?
bakerstreet
Reply #92 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:27 AM
Reply #92 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:27 AM
No, I don't think people would rally around ya even if you were someone who we all know *cough*.
"As for the pirated software comment":
None? no, i can't say that, but you didn't say none, you sald "half the work". A good deal of the work here is made by a few people, and I feel quite sure your statement is false.
"As for the pirated software comment":
None? no, i can't say that, but you didn't say none, you sald "half the work". A good deal of the work here is made by a few people, and I feel quite sure your statement is false.
kona0197
Reply #93 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:29 AM
Reply #93 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:29 AM
"Sometimes, the upper powers are wrong."
Actually I've found that if you do not abide by there views or opinions sometimes you get yelled at. I'm prtty sure I'll get yelled at for my posts in the LiteSTEP thread but it is only my opinion so who cares?
Someone around here thinks they are a GOD.
Actually I've found that if you do not abide by there views or opinions sometimes you get yelled at. I'm prtty sure I'll get yelled at for my posts in the LiteSTEP thread but it is only my opinion so who cares?
Someone around here thinks they are a GOD.
GregBN
Reply #94 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:31 AM
Reply #94 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:31 AM
Fair enough, I know that Journeyman rank and above get their work submitted automatically, and everyone else below that gets moderated....
Very well, not half the work, seeing that there are quite a large number of people I know here whom I trusted. However, all it takes is one (a couple for those harder to convince) piece of artwork out there made by pirated software to disarm any "we don't take warez kindly" argument... Takes only one false to make a entire statement false, I suppose.
Very well, not half the work, seeing that there are quite a large number of people I know here whom I trusted. However, all it takes is one (a couple for those harder to convince) piece of artwork out there made by pirated software to disarm any "we don't take warez kindly" argument... Takes only one false to make a entire statement false, I suppose.
kona0197
Reply #95 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:34 AM
Reply #95 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:34 AM
I know bunches off people who have pirated software. I can garentee that not every person here has legit software.
kona0197
Reply #96 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:38 AM
Reply #96 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:38 AM
What I meant is I bet a few people here (not me) have burrowed software from a friend and used it to do stuff that that software does. In a way that is Waraz to I think. No different then burning yourself a copy of your friends favorite music I guess.
bakerstreet
Reply #97 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:39 AM
Reply #97 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:39 AM
Youji: I don't doubt there is some work here done with Warez. I'm not gonna say that some software is fairly priced, either. There are always affordable alternatives, though. I doubt there will ever be a way for site owners to makes sure images were made on legit software.
Anyway...
The outrage wasn't really about what the Mac site did; that could have been an honest mistake, as I said in my first post. What made people get on their hind legs was how the site reacted, denying they did anything wrong and banning people who complained.
There have been lots of sites that responded well to a friendly email, re-did things the right way, and ended up posting what they wanted to. There have also been times of overreaction where your post would have been more warranted, but I don't see it this time.
Anyway...
The outrage wasn't really about what the Mac site did; that could have been an honest mistake, as I said in my first post. What made people get on their hind legs was how the site reacted, denying they did anything wrong and banning people who complained.
There have been lots of sites that responded well to a friendly email, re-did things the right way, and ended up posting what they wanted to. There have also been times of overreaction where your post would have been more warranted, but I don't see it this time.
GregBN
Reply #98 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:39 AM
Reply #98 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:39 AM
My point, kona0197, is that not many people are willing to admit they use pirated software. I've stayed around enough to see many of the kazaa threads turned into "admin-dislike" threads.
When a person has an impressive image of making great pieces of art, we, personally, do not like "damaging" that image with the use of pirates software. Sure, a site has to keep up their image of "purity" and "goodness." I'm pretty sure Frogboy doesn't want a lawsuit on his hands for pirated software usage, or hosting pirated software. Any hosting service would have that in their lisence agreement.
However, they aren't internet cops. If someone stole my nice harley, I can't go hunt them down and make them pay. Likewise, my friends can't hunt them down and make them pay either just because they're part of the "neighbourhood watch".
Same idea. Some people are over doing it, and many don't take well to criticism.
When a person has an impressive image of making great pieces of art, we, personally, do not like "damaging" that image with the use of pirates software. Sure, a site has to keep up their image of "purity" and "goodness." I'm pretty sure Frogboy doesn't want a lawsuit on his hands for pirated software usage, or hosting pirated software. Any hosting service would have that in their lisence agreement.
However, they aren't internet cops. If someone stole my nice harley, I can't go hunt them down and make them pay. Likewise, my friends can't hunt them down and make them pay either just because they're part of the "neighbourhood watch".
Same idea. Some people are over doing it, and many don't take well to criticism.
kona0197
Reply #99 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:42 AM
Reply #99 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:42 AM
Like I said, someone here thinks they are a GOD. They do overdo it sometimes, yes. I was agreeing with you, not disagreeing. 
GregBN
Reply #100 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:51 AM
Reply #100 Monday, April 21, 2003 12:51 AM
They didn't care about it, and yes, that may have been an offense to many of you (myself included), but it is their site, and it is their will to ban whom they don't like coming around harrassing their environment (even though to us, they broke the environemnt first). They may also believe they didn't do anything wrong.
It is your responsibility and mine to explain with well phrased reasoning and example to why their actions are wrong. If they don't see uploading another artists' work for enjoyment as stealing... people stomping all over them telling them they are stealing will only confuse them.
Just so you know, not everyone speak English as a first language. Sometimes, what you people write are hard to understand if one doesn't understand English moderately.
Those who responded with good will are those we should thank, not say that "it should have been that way". When people over react, it's also understandable. We, as a community, charged in there with swords drawn, ready to draw blood if they didn't do what we command them to do, at least, that's how I saw it.
I, too, have dealt with my share of rippers. They make my blood boil... but there's always the option to either do it nicely or savagely. However, always notify the artist first. I don't know if charging in there before Dangeruss was even notified first was a wise idea. If Dangeruss needs back up flaming the group, please, rally behind him and give him all the support he needs.
It is your responsibility and mine to explain with well phrased reasoning and example to why their actions are wrong. If they don't see uploading another artists' work for enjoyment as stealing... people stomping all over them telling them they are stealing will only confuse them.
Just so you know, not everyone speak English as a first language. Sometimes, what you people write are hard to understand if one doesn't understand English moderately.
Those who responded with good will are those we should thank, not say that "it should have been that way". When people over react, it's also understandable. We, as a community, charged in there with swords drawn, ready to draw blood if they didn't do what we command them to do, at least, that's how I saw it.
I, too, have dealt with my share of rippers. They make my blood boil... but there's always the option to either do it nicely or savagely. However, always notify the artist first. I don't know if charging in there before Dangeruss was even notified first was a wise idea. If Dangeruss needs back up flaming the group, please, rally behind him and give him all the support he needs.
Please login to comment and/or vote for this skin.
Welcome Guest! Please take the time to register with us.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:
- Richer content, access to many features that are disabled for guests like commenting on the forums and downloading skins.
- Access to a great community, with a massive database of many, many areas of interest.
- Access to contests & subscription offers like exclusive emails.
- It's simple, and FREE!
|
|
Page 5 of 7 | |
|
|---|
Reply #81 Saturday, April 19, 2003 5:58 PM
http://forum.deviantart.com/1136482
Anyone who wants Dangeruss's tank.....I can forward it to the world royalty free as I legitimately downloaded it from a site who claims to have hosted it legally.
Jafo dons dirty raincoat and stands on street corner flogging warez and car radios to passers-by....
moshi, you are 'right'...it's just a toy site whose admins couldn't even form a gestalt...but think of it as the thin edge of the wedge.
If they believe they do nothing wrong, perhaps others will emulate...