Here's how I see it...

IMO

Tuesday, July 8, 2008 by vStyler | Discussion: Community

 

  In reading a recent thread I felt the need to say a couple of things..Personally, I would like to say I agree with IR, I don't think the threads title reflected the exact motive of its contents and I would have posted but could not...so with that said..

As far as tips go, there isn't some book of hidden tips and tricks we keep to ourselves, as problems arise when skinning I try to attack them with vigor, with stubborness, hard work and amibition, part of skinning IS figuring these things out, SKinning is like anything else in life, the harder you work, the more pride you take, the less apt you are to ask for help... the better your chances of success are. Ive been skinning a LONG time and can , with pride and honestly say 98% of it I learned by myself.. through trial and error, long hours, lots of coffee and cigarettes and hundreds of sleepless nights.

I highly doubt Davinci became a Master at his trade by giving up and asking for help everytime he came across what he deemed an insurmountable road block. Know this.. If you try something enough times.. it will work.. If you have the tenacity to keep at it until it's figured out no matter what.. then your well on your way to becoming a master of whatever your heart desires.

I firmly believe that one should not even ask for help until one has thouroughly exhausted body and mind in defiance of a problem, then and only then, when you have tried your best.. explorered EVERY avenue, at your wits end, then.. put your pride aside.. no matter how much it hurts.. and finally buckle.

The sense that people should be entitled to help, to less than glowing praise of their work..to me.. is unacceptable, It seems to me a very liberal philosophy and one that again.. to me.. holds no water. Now obviously.. I have zero problems helping people further their skinning knowledge, I love to help, I imagine that over the last year or so or more, other than maybe Cavan1 that Myself, IR and NT have contributed to 95% of the WB skinning help that has been given on this site so again.. I am not oppsed to helping but I do, in no way, feel obligated to hand out help or critique more mildly ot untruly because of my status on this site.

I see no need for a special Channel, or thread, or round table to be instigated.. when help is asked for.. almost 100% of the time.. it is given..and usually by myself, NT or IR. I would like to think that this in some small part is appreciated but judging by a few comments in the other thread, sometimes I wonder if it's worth it.

To speak to what ignited the post I refer to I shall only say this.... NT said under no uncertain terms exactly what many amongst us were thinking.. was it harsh?.. yes.. but sometimes a blunt sword is better than a speeding bullet. I do not disagree with the main point he made, I completely agree with him. Could he have said it in a more compassionate manner? Sure, he could have, however, this wasn't the first time this had been brought to the attention of the skinner, I myself, had a couple of times mentioned almost exactly the same thing and I wasn't the only one. Point being, nicety was not working. If Craig had not said what was said.. someone else was going to.

 For me the main reason was this.. Its VERY hard to see someone skipping all the work, breaking all the cardinal rules and then bumping those offending skins constantly to the top of page one, knocking down work that some folks spend months on. Straight and simple. If it wrong to think that is wrong. Then 7 out of 7 so called community elders, Masters, Mods alike.. were also wrong. If someone can explain to me why it might have been acceptable then please feel free.

I support stronger critique, less tolerance of the above tactics and a more open dialog when it comes to these things, I think WC may be a better place because of it.

Hard work makes a great skinner\ person. Work hard, don't give up, get it done... be proud.

 

 

 

 

 

First Previous Page 3 of 7 Next Last
2of3
Reply #41 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 7:47 PM
Masters could produce such a curriculum and offer it for sale for those that are interested in advancing their skills.


For sale?
WebGizmos
Reply #42 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 8:23 PM
That's funny! Karma funny!




messiah1
Reply #43 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 8:27 PM
Have you ever seen a CBT Nugget course?


Not sure about the Nugget part but I create training CBT's for the company I work for. I love doing those things.
Jafo
Reply #44 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 8:58 PM

I highly doubt Davinci became a Master at his trade by giving up and asking for help everytime he came across what he deemed an insurmountable road block.

You know, 'students of Architecture' up until the early 20th century still studied under the apprenticeship system...taken 'under wing' by an existing Master of the trade...and when I went through in '72 you were still required to work employed by another Architect for 12 months PRIOR to ultimately qualifying.

It is NEVER all/only about 'work it out for yourself - trial-and-error'....there's plenty of room for third party assistance, Q and A, etc.

[again with the old anecdotes...but...] I remember the time a chap called Neil asked a skinner 'how the heck did you get WB to do that?' [or words to that effect].

EVERYONE can learn from others.....

EVERYONE ....

Xiandi
Reply #45 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 8:58 PM
It took me almost a week to figure out that the "IE Tabs Corners and Bottom" were actually transparent bitmaps. Now they look and work fine....


WHAT?????   What do you mean?
Just make them magic pink squares and it will work fine? I have been banging my head on those stupid things for days!!!!   Well, at least you saved me from creating yet another post about something I couldn't figure out.
TheD2JBug
Reply #46 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 9:01 PM
Yah and Jimi Hendrix made up all his guitar riffs himself too
PuterDudeJim
Reply #47 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 9:16 PM
My turn...I don't even pretend to be in the same realm as you masters, not for a minute. And I am not going to agree or disagree with any of this thread. I do wish to say this: I used to ask Fairyy~ for use of her widgets, and was granted use, but was nicely urged to make my own. She used to talk to me about margins and stuff. I still don't know a lot about margins, but thanks to Karen's urging, I started making my own. I went around and around with I.R. to get permission to make a Knot Vista DX theme. He worked me hard until I met his approval. I thought " Man, this guy is picky! " But he helped me to become a little better at what I do by making me learn. RomanDA could easily write any script I might need, but instead, he helped me a little, pointed me in the right direction, and then I had to do something for myself. I could go on. My point is that I personally have been helped by several masters, and others, and I owe them for where I am now. And believe me, I have a long way to go.


I wish to take this opportunity to thank those who have helped me, and you know who you are, and I hope someday to be able to help someone. I may never be a master, but I would like to do a master's work. (I stole that from someone on this site, but it is how I feel.)
PuterDudeJim
Reply #48 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 9:18 PM
Oh, BTW. I can't get magic pink to work for me.   
Phoon
Reply #49 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 9:22 PM
For sale?


yes 2 of 3, for sale. An advanced course which is above and beyond a normal manual.  
Such an endeavor would be quite time consuming and those that created it should be entitled to compensation. You don't get free advanced courses in other applications for free do you?
Island Dog
Reply #50 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 9:24 PM
That's great news ID, and again I'm all for helping when and if I can, the root of my post was merely to say expect to work hard and reap the rewards of doing so.


John, I know you help others, you have helped me on several occasions.  I agree people need to work hard, but I also would like to see more community involvement has a whole.


That wouldn't happen to be in a downloadable/printable form would it? That would be cool!


As far I know, it's going to be released in several different formats.  Not all at once, but we plan to make this easily accessible.





LightStar
Reply #51 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 9:35 PM
An SKS 6 Manual? Yes!!!!!!

You have definitely made my day! (Or afternoon, or night, what the heck time is it?)
Jafo
Reply #52 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 9:40 PM

what the heck time is it?)

Wednesday, LightStar...

messiah1
Reply #53 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 10:30 PM
what the heck time is it?)


Wednesday, LightStar...  


Hey Jafo, since yer in the future what am I having for breakfast tomorrow...my Wednesday?  
sydneysiders
Reply #54 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 10:42 PM

excellent read...post & comments......


since yer in the future what am I having for breakfast tomorrow...my Wednesday?


bananas...   
vStyler
Reply #55 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 10:55 PM
Hey Jafo, since yer in the future what am I having for breakfast tomorrow...my Wednesday?


A steady stream of dock making with a sprinkling of Xion conceptualization.

  
eieio
Reply #56 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 10:58 PM
For me the main reason was this.. Its VERY hard to see someone skipping all the work, breaking all the cardinal rules and then bumping those offending skins constantly to the top of page one, knocking down work that some folks spend months on. Straight and simple. If it wrong to think that is wrong. Then 7 out of 7 so called community elders, Masters, Mods alike.. were also wrong. If someone can explain to me why it might have been acceptable then please feel free.


It's 'acceptable' John because that's the way the Wincustomize system is designed.

On the one hand, it's difficult to blame someone for using the system to their benefit ... doesn't mean what they do is right; if their intention is gaming the system.

On the other hand, it's ultimately up to WC to 'discourage' that type of behavior; if WC elects to do so.

If these avenues are left open after being alerted by the most senior members of the community ... well, it's inevitable that anyone using the system in such a manner for their benefit would eventually be called on it.


The question is ... is that how WC would like to see those things handled?
ZubaZ
Reply #57 Wednesday, July 9, 2008 12:30 AM
It's 'acceptable' John because that's the way the Wincustomize system is designed.

On the one hand, it's difficult to blame someone for using the system to their benefit ... doesn't mean what they do is right; if their intention is gaming the system.

On the other hand, it's ultimately up to WC to 'discourage' that type of behavior; if WC elects to do so.

If these avenues are left open after being alerted by the most senior members of the community ... well, it's inevitable that anyone using the system in such a manner for their benefit would eventually be called on it.


The question is ... is that how WC would like to see those things handled?
There are ways to try to game the system.  The mods are aware of most of them.  Defining the game can be hard though.  Reuploading may get you on the front page . . but kills download count, etc.  The moderators are constantly trying to  . . be moderate in what they do and handle things privately with those who may be  . . misunderstandign how the system works and what kind of community we have.  It's not an easy job sometimes.

We try not to be the forum or gallery police and we are lucky enough not to have to be very often.  Sometimes it sucks that we have to be more involved in abuses.  If you see it, let us know.  We may not handle it like you want but I assure you it will be addressed.  and really, have I ever led any of you* astray before?





*"you" excludes Zoomba, Po', RomanDA, Bichur, 2of3, messiah1, IRB, vStyler, Jafo, frogboy, andrew_, Bebi; chet, Seabass, Milksama, Night Train, any of the Journeyman, my wife, Karma Girl, Quentin, Starkers, WebGizmos, any girls or women I have dated, my parents, Bilbo, MommaTee, HG_Eliminator, lasse, WOM, Hankers, CorkyO, and butch123
2of3
Reply #58 Wednesday, July 9, 2008 4:14 AM
*"you" excludes Zoomba, Po', RomanDA, Bichur, 2of3, messiah1, IRB, vStyler, Jafo, frogboy, andrew_, Bebi; chet, Seabass, Milksama, Night Train, any of the Journeyman, my wife, Karma Girl, Quentin, Starkers, WebGizmos, any girls or women I have dated, my parents, Bilbo, MommaTee, HG_Eliminator, lasse, WOM, Hankers, CorkyO, and butch123


WebGizmos
Reply #59 Wednesday, July 9, 2008 4:48 AM
I may be excluded....but I'm in good company!

Oh yeah! Theres a new gizmo on the market now for power skinners! You can create skins in 1/4 the time now!

basj
Reply #60 Wednesday, July 9, 2008 9:40 AM
Wow looking at that picture sure some up what skinning feels like to me these days.. where the fun in that?

Please login to comment and/or vote for this skin.

Welcome Guest! Please take the time to register with us.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:

  • Richer content, access to many features that are disabled for guests like commenting on the forums and downloading skins.
  • Access to a great community, with a massive database of many, many areas of interest.
  • Access to contests & subscription offers like exclusive emails.
  • It's simple, and FREE!



web-wc01