Here's how I see it...
IMO
Tuesday, July 8, 2008 by vStyler | Discussion: Community
In reading a recent thread I felt the need to say a couple of things..Personally, I would like to say I agree with IR, I don't think the threads title reflected the exact motive of its contents and I would have posted but could not...so with that said..
As far as tips go, there isn't some book of hidden tips and tricks we keep to ourselves, as problems arise when skinning I try to attack them with vigor, with stubborness, hard work and amibition, part of skinning IS figuring these things out, SKinning is like anything else in life, the harder you work, the more pride you take, the less apt you are to ask for help... the better your chances of success are. Ive been skinning a LONG time and can , with pride and honestly say 98% of it I learned by myself.. through trial and error, long hours, lots of coffee and cigarettes and hundreds of sleepless nights.
I highly doubt Davinci became a Master at his trade by giving up and asking for help everytime he came across what he deemed an insurmountable road block. Know this.. If you try something enough times.. it will work.. If you have the tenacity to keep at it until it's figured out no matter what.. then your well on your way to becoming a master of whatever your heart desires.
I firmly believe that one should not even ask for help until one has thouroughly exhausted body and mind in defiance of a problem, then and only then, when you have tried your best.. explorered EVERY avenue, at your wits end, then.. put your pride aside.. no matter how much it hurts.. and finally buckle.
The sense that people should be entitled to help, to less than glowing praise of their work..to me.. is unacceptable, It seems to me a very liberal philosophy and one that again.. to me.. holds no water. Now obviously.. I have zero problems helping people further their skinning knowledge, I love to help, I imagine that over the last year or so or more, other than maybe Cavan1 that Myself, IR and NT have contributed to 95% of the WB skinning help that has been given on this site so again.. I am not oppsed to helping but I do, in no way, feel obligated to hand out help or critique more mildly ot untruly because of my status on this site.
I see no need for a special Channel, or thread, or round table to be instigated.. when help is asked for.. almost 100% of the time.. it is given..and usually by myself, NT or IR. I would like to think that this in some small part is appreciated but judging by a few comments in the other thread, sometimes I wonder if it's worth it.
To speak to what ignited the post I refer to I shall only say this.... NT said under no uncertain terms exactly what many amongst us were thinking.. was it harsh?.. yes.. but sometimes a blunt sword is better than a speeding bullet. I do not disagree with the main point he made, I completely agree with him. Could he have said it in a more compassionate manner? Sure, he could have, however, this wasn't the first time this had been brought to the attention of the skinner, I myself, had a couple of times mentioned almost exactly the same thing and I wasn't the only one. Point being, nicety was not working. If Craig had not said what was said.. someone else was going to.
For me the main reason was this.. Its VERY hard to see someone skipping all the work, breaking all the cardinal rules and then bumping those offending skins constantly to the top of page one, knocking down work that some folks spend months on. Straight and simple. If it wrong to think that is wrong. Then 7 out of 7 so called community elders, Masters, Mods alike.. were also wrong. If someone can explain to me why it might have been acceptable then please feel free.
I support stronger critique, less tolerance of the above tactics and a more open dialog when it comes to these things, I think WC may be a better place because of it.
Hard work makes a great skinner\ person. Work hard, don't give up, get it done... be proud.
Reply #22 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 5:03 PM
Reply #23 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 5:09 PM
Yeah you are right my friend. I made my first Vista skin in 2005 and it was up at Deviant Art, but since that time I think every second person has borrowed pieces from it but forgot to ask. I believe that Deviant Art must have hundreds of them still and not really much I can do because there are just too many. But to stop it anyways I removed my gallery yesterday from Deviant ARt as well as from here. Why from here I am not gonna get into that right now but maybe in the future. And you know another problem at D.A. is some people did ask me, so, if I was to go after them, I might go after the person who did ask me, and that wouldnt be fair so basically I just dont say nothing. What can you do hunh?
Reply #24 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 5:10 PM
- ooops, sometimes my inner monologue becomes my outer monologue
.... sorry, I just had to get some of my wiggles out.
I will say this (aside from my comment above), this discussion is very mature thus far, let's keep it going that way.
Reply #25 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 5:12 PM
SkinStudio can be intimidating to new users, and I think SKS6 has done a great job at making it more friendly for people to use. The SKS6 guide is complete and is just going through some format changes, and should hopefully be released in the next few weeks. That will be a great resource for people to start with as it takes a user through the complete process of making a skin, from a beginners points of view. The thing that will fill the gap is more experienced users to help fill in the gaps or give their perspective on skinning a particular part of the UI.
I do agree people need to take the initiate and get started on their own, but I think tips and help from the community as a whole, epsecially seasoned skinners, will be a big help.
Reply #26 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 5:18 PM
Thanks for the good news ID.
Reply #27 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 5:22 PM
That's great news ID, and again I'm all for helping when and if I can, the root of my post was merely to say expect to work hard and reap the rewards of doing so.
Reply #28 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 5:24 PM
That wouldn't happen to be in a downloadable/printable form would it? That would be cool! One of the reasons I haven't even attempted a WB skin yet is one...because of my health...its hard enough sitting here for hours doing docks and trying to figure some stuff out...and I can't even begin to imagine the stuff you seasoned WB skinners go through. Second because I haven't a clue where to even start without at least some form of tutorial. Docks were easy to figure out on my own...but WB's is a whole other realm.
Reply #29 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 5:31 PM
Its the same figuring out, just more of it.
Reply #30 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 5:38 PM
It goes something like this... Do they HAVE to be differently sized in IE7 than Windows Explorer? Does the stupid little arrow have to stretch in one instance and not in another? hmmmm. the background image doesn't seem to match the recommended image size. Lemme try this.... nope...lemme try this...nope..lemme try this... that's better, will it work.....fart! Well maybe if I...nope.... OH this will definately work.... getting there.... to be continued.......
Reply #31 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 6:03 PM
For now.. best solution - recommend people use small icons in IE7 or the Large sized back forward arrows and background will look awkward.
Long term solution, Neil, add skinning of large icons\background as seperate images in IE7.
Reply #33 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 6:06 PM
There's a tip for ya.
It took me almost a week to figure out that the "IE Tabs Corners and Bottom" were actually transparent bitmaps. Now they look and work fine....
As far as the skinning goes, in all the years uploading skins, I almost "never" get any constructive feedback. It's always the same old...looks good or I don't like it. It's hard to grow as an artist like that. You have to basically teach yourself, which is what I've done.
I've helped a lot of people and even took some under my wing. It's all hit and miss from there...
Good read V.
Reply #34 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 6:10 PM
Reply #35 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 6:13 PM
Reply #36 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 6:32 PM
Don't get me started Ross.
Reply #37 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 6:33 PM
I really appreciate that Craig...really I do...but I wouldn't be so cruel as to impose on you like that. Creating the docks for everyone's skins keeps me busy. But if I ever get the energy to give it a realistic shot at creating a WB I'll keep that in mind. I have ideas for some but its more a matter of health problems right now than anything else for me to even consider it for now.
And you don't owe me a thing Craig! If it weren't for the hard work you guys put into skinning I'd have nothing to do but sit here and play with a $2000 deck of cards.
Sounds almost like your making docks.
If I can one day get you & V in the same room...I'll bring a bushel of apples....a case of shooters and smokes.
Reply #38 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 6:46 PM
That's funny! Karma funny!
Reply #39 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 6:47 PM
me too, first time :two hours
second time :an hour
third time : half an hour....
next time : hopefully LESS........
Reply #40 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 7:18 PM
Have you ever seen a CBT Nugget course? Very very nice format for learning something. Perhaps a collaboration between Stardock and some Masters could produce such a curriculum and offer it for sale for those that are interested in advancing their skills. All sides win with something like that.
Please login to comment and/or vote for this skin.
Welcome Guest! Please take the time to register with us.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:
- Richer content, access to many features that are disabled for guests like commenting on the forums and downloading skins.
- Access to a great community, with a massive database of many, many areas of interest.
- Access to contests & subscription offers like exclusive emails.
- It's simple, and FREE!







Reply #21 Tuesday, July 8, 2008 4:43 PM
Another clear glass Vista clone preceded by a colored glass Vista clone.
I have an enormous amount of respect(awe,actually) for the masters that have put so much time and effort into their work.You have earned the title,carry it proudly, just not as a weapon.
I was looking at things from a visitor/non-skinners perspective,and I'm sorry but the comments looked unprofessional from that standpoint.I don't mean to offend anybody.Thanks for letting me have my say.