So, what's up with Stardock and Object Desktop?

Thursday, September 1, 2011 by gmknobl | Discussion: WinCustomize Talk

I was a longtime user of Object Desktop.  For many, many years I subscribed and enjoyed getting new skins to apply to my computer.  I still use Xav73's skins to this day.  The lack of update to some programs was an issue at times but things generally got done.  Then Impulse came out and we were told it would be wonderful and great and a new version of OD would come out and it would be world changing. 

Not so much.

Impulse did keep things updated but I never saw much change in what was available that I wanted to use.  Windowblinds still worked pretty well but the Mycolors stuff that attempted to take over for suites never worked right on Windows 7 for me and then several things started breaking that I'd been using for some time.  I'd say it was my system except this happened on all windows 7 installs I tried it on.  I found I had to do more fiddling to get things skinned properly.  Personally, I still use suites and prefer them.  It's too bad some of Xav73's objects he created for the desktop won't work under 7.

Impulse always seemed like just a way to push users to get games and advertise to us and get us to buy buy buy when nothing was really changing to make for a new GUI experience.  Desktop X can kinda sorta make a complete change to your experience but it's not any different from what I can see from it's XP incarnation.  Screensavers are sorta animated now but nothing earth shattering.

So, all this is to say, I didn't see much changing after I changed to Win 7 and installed OD.  Really, it's nice and all but it's not moving forward.  Things still take a lot of work if you want to skin your computer like the Enterprise (but why would you want to?) for example.  And if I have to do lots of work to get everything just right it's not worth the $35 to re-up every year.  Therefore, last year I let my OD subscription lapse for the first time in a long while.  Today, I went back to see if anything new had been done by Stardock only to find the latest releases of new on the website are still TWO YEARS OLD!  If the website is posting news that's that old, then I'm willing to bet the products haven't moved forward at all since I let my sub lapse.  So, it would be a total waste of my money to re-subscribe.

What I want to hear from all you guys out there is this: give me a reason, give me several reasons why I should buy OD again.  Why should I buy Stardock's stuff now?  I don't want Impulse pushed games; that's not what I'm here for.  I see Impulse is, mercifully, going away after the corporate <scam> buyout that I found rather revolting anyway.  What I want is new skins that do new things to my GUI.  What I want is the EASY ability to do wholesale changes to my GUI, not so it looks like OS/X but looks completely different, unique and fun to use and look at.  I want that new GUI to make the use of my computer easier.  That's what I want.  Is Stardock and OD going to move forward and provide this?

Anyone, Bueller, Bueller?

First Previous Page 2 of 5 Next Last
Bebi Bulma
Reply #21 Thursday, September 1, 2011 6:17 PM

DaveRI

What I want to hear from all you guys out there is this: give me a reason, give me several reasons why I should buy OD again.
Not a ridiculous request.  Anybody want to take that one?

Good question.

As is stands right now, I'm not even sure when my subs run out (due to muck ups in the way things are being handled now...not a good omen this was fixed). I think my WC sub runs out next year...and I honestly can't think of a good reason to renew. The only reason I can think of is the Master skin discount. This version of WC went live a few years ago, and there are *still* lingering bugs that never got fixed. Why should I renew if the money I'm giving isn't being put towards fixing the site and maintaining it?

As for OD....I got the whole package because it was a better deal. I got a ton of awesome programs and updates to go with them, all for a pretty hefty discount compared to getting them separately. But with things the way they are now...it might actually make more financial sense to get them separate. ODNT works as a subscription: I get free update for as long as my sub is current (1 year subs). After that year, no more updates. With how slowly the updates are coming out, I might get only a handful of updates during my sub (and then they might totally FUBAR my system, as with the latest WB update). Compare that to the separate purchases...I have OD+ and I can get updates up until the next major version change. OD2 came out a few years ago or so and we've only gotten a handful of updates in that time...but I'll likely get updates forever since it could be forever before it sees another major update.

For the record, I've been supporting Stardock and WC as a paying customer for over 7 years.

Philly0381
Reply #22 Thursday, September 1, 2011 6:29 PM

gmknobl if I can be of any help with using Theme Manager and the Suites function just send me a PM or email.  I will be glad to help in any way I can.  As has been said for several of the pieces of software, Theme Manager does have some things that need updating but it will work. 

I do try and keep up with the great skinners in the community but there does come times (like right now) that there are many new WBs being uploaded that I will fall behind.  With Theme Manager you can also set up your own suites that you put together just for yourself.  The suites I put together and upload will be mostly 90% themed skins.

If you want just one reason why you should subscribe again, change everything back to default on your computer (desktop wise) and stare at your screen for a little while, or as long as your eyes can take.  Updates are coming, believe it or not, you don't want to miss out on it. 

RedneckDude
Reply #23 Thursday, September 1, 2011 6:48 PM

JcRabbit
and lots of patience,

On both sides......in, a perfect world. 

RedneckDude
Reply #24 Thursday, September 1, 2011 6:50 PM

Philly, check dropbox. 

DrJBHL
Reply #25 Thursday, September 1, 2011 6:52 PM

Wizard1956
What I want is the EASY ability to do wholesale changes to my GUI

 Suites are the way to go for that purpose and there are many new ones to choose from. (Thanks, Philly) This would much easier if we had a working version of Theme Manager. 

I'd like to think that ODNT2012 will breath new life into TM, DX and Icon Packager and the steady improvements we see with WindowBlinds will continue.

Time will tell.

Indeed, Wiz and my thanks to Philly as well.

I wish folks would just realize that as much as I want to vent and want the apps yesterday, I realize all the shouting and screaming in the world won't hurry the process.

Why not?

Because there is a process through which each app and item has to go through because teams and people make them. They were doing other stuff before. So now you have tasked people and groups and people making sure it's getting done and people to check and test the apps (I venture to challenge anyone to deny what screaming there would be if they weren't well tested - and EVEN THEN they won't be perfect for every set up). 

What will?

The people themselves and their motivation. The process is in place to assure quality. It's no big secret that the people were developing Impulse and games as well as software. Brad even said everyone was working too much. Now there are more people and no Impulse. So there will be a replacement soon. There's a download page for the software until then. Jorge uses other websites to download his 2 programs which I love, but which have problems as well. So everyone is getting what they should/are entitled to with one big exception: DX. That absolutely needs to get fixed. I agree with those who have said so and have tried for some time to help people having problems with it. I've been back and forth with Support doing that. Not because I get paid to and not because it's my job. Just to help people. No one here (including me) knows how hard Dewie and Roscoe_P and everyone else in support worked to try and get Phoon going with the older, more functional DX version.

Reasons to buy OD again?

No one is telling you to buy again. Wait and see what happens.

Jorge -

I don't see anyone being driven away. 

Asking for patience and explaining what little of what's going on that I know isn't denying what they have to say. I think enough of it to answer: FOR ME, not Stardock. I don't work for Stardock and don't represent it (for the 1,000th time).

Let's see if anyone reads this any better than what I research and try hard to serve up to you.

 

Starcandy
Reply #26 Thursday, September 1, 2011 7:01 PM

I must admit that having read posts like this I've had some reservations about buying an ODNT subscription, so I've considered doing the same as Bebi and just buying one or two programs, then getting ODNT when things are better. But reading Frogboy's recent post has given me hope that change is just around the corner, so I will buy ODNT because I'm a bloody idiot with no financial sense I want to have that change on my computer, plus I'd like to become a bigger part of the community and contribute in some way.

Philly0381
If you want just one reason why you should subscribe again, change everything back to default on your computer (desktop wise) and stare at your screen for a little while

Hell no! I'd rather subject myself to a lemon juice eyebath.

JcRabbit
Reply #27 Thursday, September 1, 2011 7:23 PM

DrJBHL
Jorge uses other websites to download his 2 programs which I love, but which have problems as well.

Hey, I resent that, my programs are PURFECT! lol

DrJBHL
Reply #28 Thursday, September 1, 2011 7:42 PM

JcRabbit
Hey, I resent that, my programs are PURFECT! lol

Alomst.

Drzues
Reply #29 Thursday, September 1, 2011 8:32 PM

One post....7 comments...in 8 years and it's "want want want".

"revolting" is relative.

Oh, correction....

want want want want want.   [pays to be accurate]....
Since when is it wrong to want something you pay for? and to physicall go back and look a how may times someone has posted a comment is riduculous. Is he on trial. Is this not what a forum is for. I have to agree that beyond the initial investment, there is not much too look forward to in renewing you OD subscription. Not yet at least.

Drzues
Reply #30 Thursday, September 1, 2011 8:37 PM

vStyler
There are plenty of suites that have been assembled by Philly for my skins.., and other great, modern skins.. whats the issue exactly, all seems rather modern to me, at least as modern as Win 7 will allow.

Also, stylewise... 'Modern' has trended more minimally, there are still some good folks making 'fun' skins as well tho.

Perhaps what you need is to gripe at Microsoft.. Stardock doesn't make OS's. As far as Stardock goes.. your always free to exercise your.. free market.. will.

 

My mom always said.. I want... never gets.

 

I want a bag of hundreds.
Did you pay somebody for a bag of hundreds and did they claim that the said bag of hundreds would come with new and exciting features in the months to come?

Drzues
Reply #31 Thursday, September 1, 2011 8:43 PM

It always makes me shudder how long term customers that gave good money to Stardock over the years are treated here (so much for 'want, want, want'). Especially by You Jafo. With all given respect, but sometimes I really wonder. Ant the beg for patience maybe right if we where talking about some hobbyist freeware here, but we are not. It is a given fact that Object Desktop loses value regularly.

Some of You even didn't get the intention of the thread-starter at all and have fallen to automatic defense mode that is activated quick and often here.

 
I have to agree and will probably get flack for that, but alot of these comments look like personal attacks from people that got there feelings hurt instead of addressing the original complaint which is bang for the buck. Is this a business or not?

Drzues
Reply #32 Thursday, September 1, 2011 8:50 PM

Hankers
Not disagreeing one bit with what you said Jorge but what I see as an issue is the groundhog day repeating of the same line over and over Ad infinitum.

Things will get done when they get done and not before they are ready.  These public displays of venting will not hasten the development or updates of any Stardock products.

No one is trying to drive anyone away.
That's professional?!

Jafo
Reply #33 Thursday, September 1, 2011 8:55 PM

Drzues
Since when is it wrong to want something you pay for?

Not at all...as the OP refers to himself in the past tense..."was a longtime user".  That infers he is no longer a user.

"Last year I let my OD subscription lapse" subsequently confirms the OP is no longer a customer.

"I see Impulse is, mercifully, going away after the corporate <scam> buyout that I found rather revolting anyway." is what I find both insulting AND ill-conceived.  If ANYTHING guarantees the future prospects of Stardock's GUI software it IS THIS SALE.

Being a past anything entitles you to an entry in a history book, not an opportunity to demand [want] things differently.

It's curiously amusing that 'nothing has happened in 2 years' and yet we now have the "best windows program ever" [or some such quote] which is Fences.

WERE this in a Stardock Support forum asking for future prospects/whatever we ALL are required to respond courteously and provide assistance where due.

This instead is 'General Discussion" and 'generally' I for one am tired of the attitudes of several respondents here. <-- underlined for POLITE effect.

 

For the OP with his 'wants' [Beuller or otherwise], the sale of Impulse is causal AND effect of 'things are happening'.

I can be patient.  It's a virtue, apparently.

....and a rare one, clearly.

vStyler
Reply #34 Thursday, September 1, 2011 8:57 PM

Drzues
Did you pay somebody for a bag of hundreds and did they claim that the said bag of hundreds would come with new and exciting features in the months to come?

 

Well, I guess I havent experienced SD telling me I was going to get something I didn't, that I remember anyway.... but If that had happened, Im pretty sure that entering the fray repeatedly saying I want this, I want that, It wouldn't get me far. This is true of most businesses I have had dealings with over the years.

I've always found you catch more flies with honey... and to me, again, Imo...for what SD charges for most of their stuff, it's a pretty good value for the dollar.

 Perhaps the post to me, seemed a little on the.. 'I'm entitled'.. side.. when anyone not happy with a product, service, is free to stop paying for it.

 Again, just my personal views, folks are are free to act however they want in public, this is just my advice... for what its worth.\

.. and I'm always going to want that bag of hundreds, although I know, no one is going to just hand it over.. so I don't demand.

 

I don't agree with Jafo on much, but I do here.

DrJBHL
Reply #35 Thursday, September 1, 2011 9:04 PM

Drzues
Quoting Hankers, reply 17Not disagreeing one bit with what you said Jorge but what I see as an issue is the groundhog day repeating of the same line over and over Ad infinitum.

Things will get done when they get done and not before they are ready.  These public displays of venting will not hasten the development or updates of any Stardock products.

No one is trying to drive anyone away.That's professional?!

"Professional"? Wasn't aware Super Wizop is considered a "Profession".

And just what's wrong with what he wrote? That you don't like it? That's apparently the "standard" for for something, but just what?

 


Jafo
Reply #36 Thursday, September 1, 2011 9:10 PM

vStyler
.. and I'm always going to want that bag of hundreds, although I know, no one is going to just hand it over.. so I don't demand.

A guy in Oz got an arts grant for $20,000.  He used it to withdraw....$20,000 ... 2 packs [taped] of 100s.

He presented them to auction as 'art'.

They sold for $21 and a half thou.

Ah....taking a loss for your 'art' ....

vStyler
Reply #37 Thursday, September 1, 2011 9:15 PM

I think the call that beating the system.... or.. selling out. 

 

Either way, someone is going to complain.

Drzues
Reply #38 Thursday, September 1, 2011 9:22 PM

I dont see a demand for anything. I see an informed oppinion and a request for answers. I see a long time member being attacked for speaking his mind. I see alot of assumption but no real answers to a valid question that has been shadowed in angry response.

Drzues
Reply #39 Thursday, September 1, 2011 9:24 PM

DrJBHL
Quoting Drzues, reply 32Quoting Hankers, reply 17Not disagreeing one bit with what you said Jorge but what I see as an issue is the groundhog day repeating of the same line over and over Ad infinitum.

Things will get done when they get done and not before they are ready.  These public displays of venting will not hasten the development or updates of any Stardock products.

No one is trying to drive anyone away.That's professional?!

"Professional"? Wasn't aware Super Wizop is considered a "Profession".

And just what's wrong with what he wrote? That you don't like it? That's apparently the "standard" for for something, but just what?

 


?

DrJBHL
Reply #40 Thursday, September 1, 2011 9:30 PM

Drzues
?


Quoting and replying to your #32.

As for your #38?  

Read Jafo's #33. 

 

Please login to comment and/or vote for this skin.

Welcome Guest! Please take the time to register with us.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:

  • Richer content, access to many features that are disabled for guests like commenting on the forums and downloading skins.
  • Access to a great community, with a massive database of many, many areas of interest.
  • Access to contests & subscription offers like exclusive emails.
  • It's simple, and FREE!



web-wc01