Finally: It's good!

Friday, March 19, 2010 by Mellowe | Discussion: WinCustomize 2011 Feedback

I'm not a WinCustomize guy, but I've visited the site a few times. I was always turned off by the primitive nature of the old site. It was ugly, outdated, and unintuitive. The new site (beta) is absolutely wonderful. I think it'll go a long way in attracting new users for several reasons:

  • Clean and simple (so important!)
  • Great header (useful mouseovers are always a plus)
  • Better organization of information (news, popular skins, etc.)

Bravo!

First Previous Page 2 of 3 Next Last
Phoon
Reply #21 Friday, March 19, 2010 12:15 PM

Much of the same things were said about the current WC when it was released as well.

That does not negate the valid comments/complaints/criticism that is being given though.

ie .. the new site sux - not a valid comment

ie .. the new site sux because ''blah blah blah blah" is a valid comment ( unless your name is Ke$ha of course )

Island Dog
Reply #22 Friday, March 19, 2010 12:24 PM

Except the DesktopX library is buried so deep a proctologist was called in and we haven't seen him since.....

Took two clicks to find and be in the DX gallery.

 

And you must run a search to find your own gallery.

 

There will be ways to get to your own gallery, we just haven't implemented them yet.

RedneckDude
Reply #23 Friday, March 19, 2010 12:58 PM

Island Dog

Except the DesktopX library is buried so deep a proctologist was called in and we haven't seen him since.....


Took two clicks to find and be in the DX gallery.



 


And you must run a search to find your own gallery.


 

There will be ways to get to your own gallery, we just haven't implemented them yet.

I sit corrected.....

RedneckDude
Reply #24 Friday, March 19, 2010 12:59 PM

There will be ways to get to your own gallery, we just haven't implemented them yet.

I'm more concerned with the ability of others to get to my gallery, being the download ho I be.   lol

WebGizmos
Reply #25 Friday, March 19, 2010 1:27 PM

The desire for the new site was to make it clean and simple to navigate, and I think it's much better.

Well...they got it party right. Honestly....all change aside...it is by no means simple to navigate by a long shot. On the current site I can reach just about everything I need to with one click. Whereas currrently on the new site I need several clicks and in some cases head a dead end. I really hope that gets fixed before the big move...if not I might as well just remove 3/4 of my stuff since no one will see any of it at which point I'm just wasting server space. So far I can't find my gallery and can only get to about 6 most recent skins.

 

I think what has been written here just defines what change is, it can be good or bad and either accepted or not. What we will find though that at the end of the day change will occur, most folks just look at it and move knowing that tomorrow will bring more change.

I think if you actually put the work into creating something you might not be so cheery with your comments.

gmc2
Reply #26 Friday, March 19, 2010 1:31 PM

no offense in this, but the only positive comments beside the original post are those from staff. kind of, just a little bit possibly that those opinions are not completely unbiased. and using statements of "I remember when" doesn't necessarily make these changes for the better for the users. I can think of a many changes in my lifetime that were not for the better.

having sniveled, I like many others will get used to the changes when we are forced to do so. it is said that the site is not in it's final form, one can hope that when I have to switch that I will be pleasantly surprised, but I won't hold my breath.

WebGizmos
Reply #27 Friday, March 19, 2010 2:02 PM

one can hope that when I have to switch that I will be pleasantly surprised

 In all fairness that very wll may happen. One can hope!

And it's NOT about so much change as some keep saying...it's more about functionality!  I have to agree with some here that the functionality has been going backwards.

DrJBHL
Reply #28 Friday, March 19, 2010 3:22 PM

Fuzzy Logic
Ooh look, the site was functional once upon a time...

Reduced 38%Original 1572 x 699

I dunno, Fuzzy. I've clicked that [download] several times and nothing happens.

DrJBHL
Reply #29 Friday, March 19, 2010 3:25 PM

Island Dog
Except the DesktopX library is buried so deep a proctologist was called in and we haven't seen him since.....

Took two clicks to find and be in the DX gallery.


 

And you must run a search to find your own gallery.
 

There will be ways to get to your own gallery, we just haven't implemented them yet.

That's one more than now. And just how is that an improvement ?

karmat
Reply #30 Friday, March 19, 2010 5:06 PM

I'm still using the old site, the only thing I like about the new site is the larger thumbnails.

How can 18 thumbnails on a page versus 100 be an improvement? It seems nothing is visible, settings are never remembered so you have to reset them everytime and there is far too much clicking.

The design is not so drastically different to warrant the aggravation!

 

 

Nimbin
Reply #31 Friday, March 19, 2010 6:28 PM

how many clicks is it to find the rightclick gallery on the new site?. I couldn't find it anywhere except through my personal page. Hopefully i am wrong.

BoXXi
Reply #32 Friday, March 19, 2010 6:36 PM

The problem is, when you click that explore button, and you get that dropdown box, it only has the stardock apps in it, and I doubt the average visitor will click that "customize" word at the bottom and add all the other categories........ It took ME three visits before I noticed it.

And I can't find half the stuff I normally look at.

Jafo
Reply #33 Friday, March 19, 2010 6:53 PM

no offense in this, but the only positive comments beside the original post are those from staff. kind of, just a little bit possibly that those opinions are not completely unbiased. and using statements of "I remember when" doesn't necessarily make these changes for the better for the users.

Ah, so 'staff' are not entitled to opinions?....even when they have been here longer than anyone and thus are totally aware of the site's history....AND of its short-comings past. present and future?

When I say "I remember when skinz.org wasn't brown" Wincustomize.com rose from the 'ashes' of skinz.org.  The latter was quite famous for being brown but even that wasn't its first iteration.

If 38 years of Architecture has taught me one thing it's people have a pathological hatred towards change and are willing to fight such all the way to the Appeals Tribunals and for no better reason than because whatever the development is it is going to be DIFFERENT and 'we' can't have that.

The reality is....change indicates vitality and life, whereas the Status Quo is just a bunch of old blokes with long hair...

Please don't presume that a comment from 'staff' is a 'paid political broadcast' as it is demeaning to those who care about [and for] this Community the most...

WebGizmos
Reply #34 Friday, March 19, 2010 8:07 PM

It's just pointless complaining and pointing out the obviously bad changes.

gmc2
Reply #35 Friday, March 19, 2010 11:17 PM

I'm obviously not the only person that thinks the new WC site could be better for various reasons. Navigation does seem to be the most prominent concern and one which I agree with. You flexing and huffing isn't going to change that.

maybe it's differenct at WC but it has been my business experience that those employees that publically rag on their employer's product usually end up unemployed. I didn't mean that either of you were tottie boys and if that came off like that, I apologize. I think very highly of all of you.

but now my SD is up, and I'm wondering if there wasn't some hidden purpose in the OP?

Jafo
Reply #36 Friday, March 19, 2010 11:27 PM

maybe it's differenct at WC but it has been my business experience that those employees that publically rag on their employer's product usually end up unemployed

Yes, it's different.  Don't confuse positive opinion with fawning acquiescence....

RedneckDude
Reply #37 Saturday, March 20, 2010 12:29 PM

Yes, it's different. Don't confuse positive opinion with fawning acquiescence....

Damn, you're good......

DrJBHL
Reply #38 Saturday, March 20, 2010 12:38 PM

fawning acquiescence....

This is too much to resist..... ok, Bambi.  *doc's photoshop is on sabbatical.

 jk, Jafo...you know my heart's in the right place, although my silverware seems not to be.

PoSmedley
Reply #39 Saturday, March 20, 2010 2:05 PM

Are we ALL really THAT old?

I remember my very first PC. It was right after XP came out. I was scared out of my mind because every where I went, folks were saying what a nightmare XP was and how they would never give up Win2000. I thought I had just bought something that was destined to die on me very fast because the OS was so terrible.

Now I have Vista on one PC, 7 on another , and still have XP on the laptop.

Just out of curiosity.....How many of those opposed to the new site have caught themselves saying 'What the hell is that noise?' to something someone else had on the radio? Or 'Turn that shit down?' to their kids. Or "That's NOT music. I'll tell you what REAL rock is..."

Change is constant. So is the ability for all people to eventually become their parents...and settled in their ways.

I f***ing hate the new site, by the way. But I realize when there is only one flavor of Kool-Aid to drink, Imma gonna drink it when I get thirsty.

starkers
Reply #40 Saturday, March 20, 2010 9:02 PM

Jafo...you know my heart's in the right place, although my silverware seems not to be.

Yeah, and I had nothing to do with its disappearance.  though I do recall seeing somewhere that that was attributed to me.

Well to set the record straight... sod off, it wasn't me.  As I recall, when I was invited to dinner, and Anne cooked my favourite, curried cabbage, you made me eat out back with the dog... nowhere near yer preshus silverware.  No!!  All I got was a bowl on the back patio... and a wooden spoon to eat with.

And another thing I thought was cruel, was when I couldn't hold onto one any longer and the dog was yelping and scratching at the back door, and you wouldn't let him in.  Man's best friend, eh?? 

I f***ing hate the new site, by the way. But I realize when there is only one flavor of Kool-Aid to drink, Imma gonna drink it when I get thirsty.

That's pretty much it, isn't it.  It's pretty much like the only pub in town, and you hate the decor.... if you wanna beer badly enough, you'll sit in it.

Please login to comment and/or vote for this skin.

Welcome Guest! Please take the time to register with us.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:

  • Richer content, access to many features that are disabled for guests like commenting on the forums and downloading skins.
  • Access to a great community, with a massive database of many, many areas of interest.
  • Access to contests & subscription offers like exclusive emails.
  • It's simple, and FREE!



web-wc01